Plein air painting locations, demos and exhibits

Paint-splash shaped museum building, should we demolish and rebuild LACMA?

In an article published on June 18, 2013  "Should LACMA's Imperfection Be Erased or Embraced?" by Edward Goldman on www.kcrw.com Art Talk page,  I learned of a new proposal to demolish and rebuild LACMA.  Build in the 1960s the museum served us, residents of Greater Los Angeles, well for about fifty years.  Now the museum's director,  Michael Govan, a relative newcomer to L A and a renowned Swiss architect Peter Zumthor are proposing to do away with "old grandpa of the museum" and erect a new, cool, paint splash shaped, one level structure instead.

 

Some residents of Los Angeles apparently are not in favor of this project.  Too many people who saw this museum being built and opened are still around.  My husband, for instance, was a young trumpet player in the orchestra that played The Handel Fireworks Music conducted by Ingolf Dahl for the opening.  Back then, in the sixties, the building's design and museum's grounds seemed pretty cool.  The Japanese pavilion seems pretty elegant to me.  Everything in the museum's buildings works, nothing had deteriorated, there are no structural defect, and its only fault is that is it not perfect enough for its new director. 

 

I like the design of the new proposed museum, but don’t like the idea of demolishing the old one.  It may look like a Frankenstein to contemporaries, but when it was newly built many must have loved it, or it wouldn’t be approved.  As with most “artifacts to be” there is a time when they are too old to be “cool” and yet serve today’s needs, but are too young to be of historical and cultural value.  Many buildings that were demolished were later regretted as a loss.  Those buildings that were lucky and survived are now prized.   Wouldn’t we be repeating the same mistake by demolishing and rebuilding LACMA?  Or if you think that the buildings of the museum are old and ugly and deserve demolition, what do you think will happen to the new paint-splash shaped museum's building in fifty years.  Will our children see this museum go up and learn to love it only to see it torn down when they are old?  Shouldn't we set an example to our children on how to respect the past and appreciate it even if it is not perfect?  

Los Angeles plein air painter, Elena Roché, shares her new works, painting locations, plein air demos, workshops and art exhibits in Southern California.


Comments

5 Responses to Paint-splash shaped museum building, should we demolish and rebuild LACMA?

I also have some doubts about this new building. It seems rather extravagant to spend so much on a new building when the original is still relatively new. In fact, I like the older building much more than the Eli Broad monster that is more recent and part of the 'improved' renovation. I agree that you don't know what you have until it's gone and that I will probably be missing the old building but the forces that move these things have already made up their mind and will forge ahead regardless of those against it.

Thank you for your input, Sharon.

I agree with Elena and Sharon. The museum could become a historical treasure in the future, and should be kept so that future generations can experience the architecture of the past. Moreover, if the museum functions well, there really is no need to spend money on taking it down and building a new one. It's a sad thing when people/organizations with so much money choose to spend it so frivolously while there are many people in the world who don't even have adequate housing and food. There are plenty of other causes (cancer research, food and housing for the poor, etc.) that could put the same money to much better use. Like Sharon said, the renovation is extravagant.

Thank you, Karina. I appreciate your thoughts on this issue. Acquisition of new art for the LACMA would be money well spent. Even is they proposed to build an addition to the museum using Peter Zumthor's design that would be alright, too. But completely rebuilding the whole thing is going too far.

I moved out of CA in the early 1990s. I came of age in Southern California (Westwood/Culver boy.) I have fond memories of LACMA and the elegant (pre-1980s) original structure. First the great department stores are ruined like the classic Bonwit Teller in Beverly Hills to the magnificent Art Deco Bullocks Wilshire, both of which I was literally raised out of thru college. Now they want to ruin the museum?! Who is making these decisions or comes up with these ideas? I am so taken aback over this ridiculousness of considering taking down the original building. Wasn't it bad enough when they built that monstrosity in front of it on Wilshire in the 1980s? Now this?! This new design in my opinion is not elegant nor timeless. What I see is the typical Contemporary BS, a piece of ...I'll be kind and say I see the proposal as a hideous piece of junk that will only put another nail in the LA architectural coffin.